Brummel
776bd5432a
Observed bug in the graph viewer shipped in 66dff88: clicking `[+]` to
inline-expand a composite in `aura graph`'s HTML output renders a broken graph —
the interior nodes' edges collapse onto a single phantom node "0" with uncoloured
arrows, and the real pin docking is lost. The collapsed view and the body-drill
view both render correctly; only inline-expand breaks.
Root cause: in graph-viewer.js, genDot's `build` forms a node id by path-joining
the model keys (`cid = cpath.join("__")`). The aura model keys interior nodes by
numeric index (C23), so an inline-expanded composite yields ids like `0__0`. A
DOT identifier that begins with a digit but is not a pure numeral is invalid —
Graphviz parses `0__0` as the numeral `0` plus a leftover token, collapsing
`0__0`/`0__1`/`0__2` onto one phantom node `0`. The collapsed view survives only
because its ids are single-digit numerals (accidentally valid); the prototype
survived because it used name keys, never digit-prefixed ones. The bug surfaced
only against the real index-keyed model.
Fix: letter-prefix the id (`cid = "n" + cpath.join("__")`) so every id is a valid
identifier by construction. The fix lives in the viewer (DOT-syntax is its
responsibility), not in model_to_json — the model's index keys are correct, and
leaking the Graphviz identifier constraint into the model would be a leaky
abstraction.
RED-first guard (this establishes the project's first JS test infra, since the
viewer now carries real logic — normalizeModel + genDot — that the model golden
does not cover):
- tests/viewer_dot_ids.mjs: a headless node guard that loads the real viewer
module, discovers the expandable composites from a collapsed pass, inline-
expands them, and asserts every node id in the produced DOT is a valid Graphviz
identifier (quoted | pure numeral | bare identifier). Version-independent — it
checks the identifier grammar, not a render. The expand keys are DISCOVERED via
genDot's `expandable`, never hard-coded, so the guard cannot go vacuously green
when the fix reshapes the id (a hard-coded "0" key would stop matching "n0" and
silently test only the collapsed view — a false-green this guard refuses).
- tests/viewer_dot.rs: a Rust integration test that shells out to `node`,
wiring the guard into `cargo test --workspace`. `node` is required: if it is
absent the test fails (a skipped guard is not a guard).
- tests/fixtures/sample-model.json: the triggering fixture (numeric index keys,
a nested composite).
- graph-viewer.js: made node-loadable (typeof window/document guards + a
module.exports) so the guard can exercise the pure generator headless. This is
a test-enabler, behaviour-neutral in the browser — verified by the existing
render_html / graph_emits self-containment tests staying green and by the
expand re-rendering correctly through the vendored WASM-Graphviz.
Verified RED against the unfixed viewer (the guard trips on `0__0`/`0__1`/`0__2`
and the Rust test fails), GREEN after the prefix; full `cargo test --workspace`
green; clippy clean. Rendered the expanded state through the vendored
WASM-Graphviz to confirm the interior wires up correctly (price -> both SMA
series, SMA value -> Sub lhs/rhs, Sub -> signal, all f64-blue).
2 lines
1.3 KiB
JSON
2 lines
1.3 KiB
JSON
{"root":{"nodes":{"0":{"comp":"sma_cross"},"1":{"prim":{"type":"Exposure","role":"node","params":[["scale","f64"]],"ins":[["f64","any","signal"]],"outs":[["exposure","f64"]]}},"2":{"prim":{"type":"SimBroker","role":"node","params":[],"ins":[["f64","any","exposure"],["f64","any","price"]],"outs":[["equity","f64"]]}},"3":{"prim":{"type":"Recorder","role":"sink","params":[],"ins":[["f64","any","col[0]"]],"outs":[]}},"4":{"prim":{"type":"Recorder","role":"sink","params":[],"ins":[["f64","any","col[0]"]],"outs":[]}},"src_price":{"prim":{"type":"price","role":"source","params":[],"ins":[],"outs":[["price","f64"]]}}},"edges":[["0.o0","1.i0"],["1.o0","2.i0"],["2.o0","3.i0"],["1.o0","4.i0"],["src_price.o0","0.i0"],["src_price.o0","2.i1"]]},"composites":{"sma_cross":{"inputs":[["f64","any","price"]],"outputs":[["cross","f64"]],"nodes":{"0":{"prim":{"type":"SMA","role":"node","params":[["length","i64"]],"ins":[["f64","any","series"]],"outs":[["value","f64"]]}},"1":{"prim":{"type":"SMA","role":"node","params":[["length","i64"]],"ins":[["f64","any","series"]],"outs":[["value","f64"]]}},"2":{"prim":{"type":"Sub","role":"node","params":[],"ins":[["f64","any","lhs"],["f64","any","rhs"]],"outs":[["value","f64"]]}}},"edges":[["0.o0","2.i0"],["1.o0","2.i1"],["@price","0.i0"],["@price","1.i0"],["2.o0","#0"]]}}}
|