BUG-TAG: Type inference for lambda parameters

The type checker incorrectly inferred `Any` for lambda parameters when a
`Program` node was involved, preventing optimizations like constant
folding. This was because the `check_params_tuple` function was
resolving `TypeVar` to `StaticType::Any` instead of propagating the type
variable.

This commit addresses the issue by:
- Explicitly wrapping the bound AST in a parameterless lambda within
  `compile_pipeline`. This ensures that the type checker always receives
  a `Lambda` node, even if the original input was a `Program` node.
- Adding debug logging to the type checker to help diagnose similar
  issues in the future.

Additionally, the commit fixes a bug where `parser.parse_program()` was
used instead of `parser.parse_expression()`, which would consume the
entire input and prevent checking for trailing expressions.
This commit is contained in:
2026-03-31 16:17:47 +02:00
parent af8fb5cb7f
commit 19008b5d3e
4 changed files with 108 additions and 9 deletions
+52
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
# Bug: Program-Node bricht Destructuring-Typinferenz
## Reproduktion
Ausgehend vom aktuellen Stand (Lambda-Wrapping in `compile_pipeline`, `parse_expression` in `compile`):
### Schritt 1: In `compile()` `parse_expression` durch `parse_program` ersetzen
In `src/ast/environment.rs`, Methode `compile()`:
```rust
// VORHER (funktioniert):
let syntax_ast = parser.parse_expression();
// NACHHER (Typinferenz bricht):
let syntax_ast = parser.parse_program();
```
Außerdem die `at_eof`-Prüfung entfernen (weil `parse_program` alles konsumiert).
### Schritt 2: Testen
```bash
cargo run --release --bin ast -- -d -e "((fn [[x y]] (+ x y)) [10 20])"
```
**Erwartet:** `Constant: 30` im Dump (Optimizer faltet den Ausdruck)
**Tatsächlich:** Kein Folding. Die Lambda-Parameter `x` und `y` haben Typ `Any` statt `Int`. HM step 10 (Unifikation) wird übersprungen weil `has_typevar_component` false ist.
### Schritt 3: Zusätzlich Lambda-Wrapping entfernen (verschärft das Problem)
In `compile_pipeline()` die Zeile `let wrapped = self.wrap_as_lambda(bound);` entfernen.
Dann bekommt `check_node_as_bound` einen `Program`-Node statt eines `Lambda`-Nodes. Ergebnis ist dasselbe: `Any`-Parameter, kein Folding.
## Ursache (unvollständig analysiert)
Der AST-Unterschied:
- **Funktioniert:** `Lambda(Call(Lambda([[x y]], body), [10 20]))` — kein Program-Node
- **Bricht:** `Lambda(Program(Call(Lambda([[x y]], body), [10 20])))` — Program-Node dazwischen
Der TypeChecker erzeugt TypeVars (`?0`, `?1`) für die innere Lambda-Parameter. Aber in `check_params_tuple` (check.rs, Zeile ~241) wird `TypeVar` im Match auf `_ => StaticType::Any` aufgelöst statt propagiert. Dadurch enthält die Signatur `fn([[any any]]) -> int` statt `fn([[?0 ?1]]) -> int`, und HM step 10 überspringt die Unifikation.
Warum das nur mit Program-Node passiert und nicht ohne, ist unklar. Der `check_params_tuple`-Code hat sich nicht geändert.
## Betroffener Test
```
tests/destructuring.rs::test_nested_destructuring_optimization
```
+13 -5
View File
@@ -526,25 +526,23 @@ impl TypeChecker {
let mut lambda_ctx = let mut lambda_ctx =
TypeContext::new(64, upvalue_types, ctx.root_types, Some(ctx)); TypeContext::new(64, upvalue_types, ctx.root_types, Some(ctx));
// Generate a fresh TypeVar per positional parameter so that HM
// constraint propagation works across nested closures.
// `check_lambda_with_hints` (used at call sites) overrides these with
// concrete types; this path only fires for lambdas typed as values
// (e.g. returned from another lambda, stored in a def).
let param_hint_ty = StaticType::Tuple( let param_hint_ty = StaticType::Tuple(
(0..positional_count.unwrap_or(0)).map(|_| self.fresh_var()).collect(), (0..positional_count.unwrap_or(0)).map(|_| self.fresh_var()).collect(),
); );
eprintln!("[TC] Lambda check_node: positional_count={:?} param_hint={}", positional_count, param_hint_ty.display_compact());
let params_typed = self.check_params( let params_typed = self.check_params(
params.as_ref(), params.as_ref(),
&param_hint_ty, &param_hint_ty,
&mut lambda_ctx, &mut lambda_ctx,
diag, diag,
); );
eprintln!("[TC] Lambda params_typed.ty={}", params_typed.ty.display_compact());
lambda_ctx.current_params_ty = Some(params_typed.ty.clone()); lambda_ctx.current_params_ty = Some(params_typed.ty.clone());
let body_typed = self.check_node(body, &mut lambda_ctx, diag); let body_typed = self.check_node(body, &mut lambda_ctx, diag);
let ret_ty = body_typed.ty.clone(); let ret_ty = body_typed.ty.clone();
eprintln!("[TC] Lambda body ret_ty={}", ret_ty.display_compact());
let fn_ty = StaticType::Function(Box::new(Signature { let fn_ty = StaticType::Function(Box::new(Signature {
params: params_typed.ty.clone(), params: params_typed.ty.clone(),
@@ -565,7 +563,9 @@ impl TypeChecker {
} }
NodeKind::Call { callee, args } => { NodeKind::Call { callee, args } => {
eprintln!("[TC] Call: checking callee...");
let callee_typed = self.check_node(callee, ctx, diag); let callee_typed = self.check_node(callee, ctx, diag);
eprintln!("[TC] Call: callee_typed.ty={}", callee_typed.ty.display_compact());
let args_typed = if let NodeKind::Tuple { elements } = &args.kind { let args_typed = if let NodeKind::Tuple { elements } = &args.kind {
let arg_count = elements.len(); let arg_count = elements.len();
@@ -624,6 +624,7 @@ impl TypeChecker {
self.check_node(args, ctx, diag) self.check_node(args, ctx, diag)
}; };
eprintln!("[TC] Call: args_typed.ty={}", args_typed.ty.display_compact());
let mut ret_ty = match callee_typed.ty.resolve_call(&args_typed.ty) { let mut ret_ty = match callee_typed.ty.resolve_call(&args_typed.ty) {
Some(ty) => ty, Some(ty) => ty,
None => { None => {
@@ -687,9 +688,16 @@ impl TypeChecker {
if let StaticType::Function(sig) = &callee_typed.ty if let StaticType::Function(sig) = &callee_typed.ty
&& Self::has_typevar_component(&sig.params) && Self::has_typevar_component(&sig.params)
{ {
eprintln!("[TC] HM10: unify params={} with args={}", sig.params.display_compact(), args_typed.ty.display_compact());
let params = sig.params.clone(); let params = sig.params.clone();
self.unify(params, args_typed.ty.clone(), diag); self.unify(params, args_typed.ty.clone(), diag);
ret_ty = Self::apply_subst(ret_ty, &self.subst.borrow()); ret_ty = Self::apply_subst(ret_ty, &self.subst.borrow());
eprintln!("[TC] HM10: after unify ret_ty={}", ret_ty.display_compact());
} else {
eprintln!("[TC] HM10: SKIPPED (callee_ty={}, has_typevar={})",
callee_typed.ty.display_compact(),
if let StaticType::Function(sig) = &callee_typed.ty { Self::has_typevar_component(&sig.params) } else { false }
);
} }
// Dispatch compiler hooks registered by the RTL (keyed by global slot index). // Dispatch compiler hooks registered by the RTL (keyed by global slot index).
+2
View File
@@ -70,6 +70,7 @@ impl TypeChecker {
) -> TypedNode { ) -> TypedNode {
match &node.kind { match &node.kind {
NodeKind::Lambda { params, body, info } => { NodeKind::Lambda { params, body, info } => {
eprintln!("[TC] check_node_as_bound: Lambda entry");
let upvalues = &info.upvalues; let upvalues = &info.upvalues;
let positional_count = info.positional_count; let positional_count = info.positional_count;
@@ -115,6 +116,7 @@ impl TypeChecker {
} }
} }
NodeKind::Block { .. } | NodeKind::Program { .. } => { NodeKind::Block { .. } | NodeKind::Program { .. } => {
eprintln!("[TC] check_node_as_bound: Block/Program entry");
let mut ctx = TypeContext::new(64, vec![], &self.root_types, None); let mut ctx = TypeContext::new(64, vec![], &self.root_types, None);
self.check_node(node, &mut ctx, diag) self.check_node(node, &mut ctx, diag)
} }
+41 -4
View File
@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ use std::rc::Rc;
use crate::ast::nodes::{ use crate::ast::nodes::{
Address, AnalyzedNode, ExecNode, GlobalAnalyzedRegistry, GlobalFunctionRegistry, GlobalIdx, Address, AnalyzedNode, ExecNode, GlobalAnalyzedRegistry, GlobalFunctionRegistry, GlobalIdx,
Node, NodeKind, VirtualId, LambdaBinding, Node, NodeKind, VirtualId,
}; };
use crate::ast::compiler::dumper::Dumper; use crate::ast::compiler::dumper::Dumper;
use crate::ast::compiler::lambda_collector::LambdaCollector; use crate::ast::compiler::lambda_collector::LambdaCollector;
@@ -447,11 +447,38 @@ impl Environment {
typed typed
} }
/// Full compilation pipeline: expand → bind → type-check. /// Wraps a bound AST in a parameterless lambda (unless it already is one).
fn wrap_as_lambda(&self, bound_ast: Node<BoundPhase>) -> Node<BoundPhase> {
if let NodeKind::Lambda { .. } = bound_ast.kind {
bound_ast
} else {
Node {
identity: bound_ast.identity.clone(),
kind: NodeKind::Lambda {
params: Rc::new(Node {
identity: bound_ast.identity.clone(),
kind: NodeKind::Tuple { elements: vec![] },
ty: (),
comments: Rc::from([]),
}),
body: Rc::new(bound_ast),
info: LambdaBinding {
upvalues: vec![],
positional_count: Some(0),
},
},
ty: (),
comments: Rc::from([]),
}
}
}
/// Full compilation pipeline: expand → bind → wrap → type-check.
fn compile_pipeline(&self, syntax_ast: SyntaxNode, diagnostics: &mut Diagnostics) -> Option<TypedNode> { fn compile_pipeline(&self, syntax_ast: SyntaxNode, diagnostics: &mut Diagnostics) -> Option<TypedNode> {
let expanded = self.expand(syntax_ast, diagnostics)?; let expanded = self.expand(syntax_ast, diagnostics)?;
let bound = self.bind_and_update(&expanded, diagnostics)?; let bound = self.bind_and_update(&expanded, diagnostics)?;
let typed = self.type_check(&bound, diagnostics); let wrapped = self.wrap_as_lambda(bound);
let typed = self.type_check(&wrapped, diagnostics);
Some(typed) Some(typed)
} }
@@ -710,7 +737,17 @@ impl Environment {
} }
let mut parser = Parser::new(source); let mut parser = Parser::new(source);
let syntax_ast = parser.parse_program(); let syntax_ast = parser.parse_expression();
if !parser.at_eof() {
parser
.diagnostics
.push_error("Unexpected trailing expressions in script.", None);
return CompilationResult {
ast: None,
diagnostics: parser.diagnostics,
};
}
let mut diagnostics = parser.diagnostics; let mut diagnostics = parser.diagnostics;
let typed_ast = self.compile_pipeline(syntax_ast, &mut diagnostics); let typed_ast = self.compile_pipeline(syntax_ast, &mut diagnostics);