claude
63711a1d3a
Downstream-author fieldtest of the #300 surface, public interface only, real GER40 archive. All four axes hold: the closed generate -> show -> hand-extend -> re-register -> run loop (2-cell extended campaign), the typed stop grammar's clap rejections, bare plateau's content-id identity with plateau:mean, and the show read-back (byte-identical, no framing) with a clean unknown-id refusal. Findings routed: 1 bug (show outside a project blames the id instead of the missing Aura.toml — RED-first fix follows), 2 friction items filed to the tracker (opaque process-document select refusal; no prefix-id hint on show), 4 working (carry-on). The fieldtest spec survives git-ignored as the next planning cycle's reference input. refs #300
48 lines
2.2 KiB
Markdown
48 lines
2.2 KiB
Markdown
# df — example 3 — bare `plateau` vs explicit spellings (Axis 3)
|
|
|
|
Task: confirm the CLI `--select plateau` sugar is content-id-identical
|
|
to `--select plateau:mean`, distinct from the other spellings, refuses
|
|
garbage cleanly, and check whether the alias carries into a hand-authored
|
|
process *document*. Binary @ a12617bb.
|
|
|
|
## CLI --select: content-id identity (walkforward over GER40, same --name)
|
|
|
|
campaign8 = first 8 hex of the generated campaign content id:
|
|
|
|
--select plateau -> campaign8 = e35e493e
|
|
--select plateau:mean -> campaign8 = e35e493e <- IDENTICAL
|
|
--select argmax -> campaign8 = eeede651
|
|
--select plateau:worst -> campaign8 = ea1f4e3a
|
|
|
|
`campaign runs` confirms plateau and plateau:mean collapse to ONE stored
|
|
id (e35e493ea4a9...d13acc, run 0 + run 1), argmax and plateau:worst are
|
|
separate ids. Confirms the cycle claim: the two spellings generate a
|
|
content-id-identical campaign.
|
|
|
|
## CLI refuses an unknown spelling (usage lists the accepted set)
|
|
|
|
$ aura walkforward ... --select plateau:bogus
|
|
aura: Usage: aura walkforward ... [--select <argmax|plateau|plateau:mean|
|
|
plateau:worst>] ...
|
|
$ aura walkforward ... --select garbage (same usage refusal)
|
|
|
|
The `--select` help string also documents it:
|
|
`argmax | plateau (alias for plateau:mean) | plateau:mean | plateau:worst`.
|
|
|
|
## the alias does NOT carry into a process document (df_3_..._REFUSED.json)
|
|
|
|
$ aura process validate df_3_select_plateau_process_REFUSED.json [exit 1]
|
|
aura: process document: block std::sweep: unknown select rule "plateau"
|
|
|
|
$ aura process validate <same doc with "select":"plateau:mean"> [exit 0]
|
|
process document valid (intrinsic): 1 pipeline blocks, 0 gate predicates
|
|
|
|
Outcome: the CLI-flag behaviour and identity claim are WORKING and
|
|
documented (help + usage). The FRICTION is the document-side refusal:
|
|
`unknown select rule "plateau"` neither enumerates the accepted rules
|
|
(argmax | plateau:mean | plateau:worst — as `aura process introspect
|
|
--block std::sweep` would) nor bridges bare `plateau` -> `plateau:mean`.
|
|
In the document-first hand-extend workflow this cycle is about, an author
|
|
who learned bare `plateau` at the CLI will paste it into a document and
|
|
hit an opaque refusal.
|