Skills/fieldtest/SKILL.md

---
name: fieldtest
description: Orchestrator-dispatched only, after audit closes clean (or with ratified drift only), when the orchestrator judges the iteration is complete and wants a field test. Picks 2-4 real-world tasks within the cycle's scope (probe tier, for a single-axis surface delta: 1-2 tasks on that axis), implements each as a downstream consumer of the project, runs them, and writes a friction-and-bug spec. The spec feeds the next plan as a reference. Implementer simulates a downstream user who has only the public interface — never the project's implementation source.
---

# fieldtest — usability field test for a shipped cycle

> **Violating the letter of these rules is violating the spirit.**

## Overview

`audit` measures drift between the design ledger and what the
codebase claims to do. `fieldtest` measures something audit
cannot: whether the project, *as it now ships*, is usable by
a downstream consumer who has only the public interface to
work from. If a freshly shipped feature is awkward to reach
for, or if the public docs leave a corner ambiguous that real
usage immediately exercises, the cycle has shipped a latent
debt — even when audit reports `clean`.

The skill produces a friction-and-bug spec that the next
iteration's `planner` consumes as a reference. The spec sits
next to cycle-design specs under `docs/specs`, with a
`fieldtest-` prefix in the slug.

The substantive process — read the design ledger + cycle spec
+ recent iter/audit commit bodies, pick the dispatched tier's
examples, implement each as a downstream consumer, run
the result, classify findings, write the spec — lives in
`agents/fieldtester.md`. That file also carries the spec
template, the source-isolation discipline (no reading under
the project's code roots or its benchmark directory, if it has
one — its CLAUDE.md project facts), and the per-finding
classification rules. This skill file only governs trigger,
dispatch, and handoff.

## Two scopes: per-cycle and milestone

`fieldtest` runs at two scopes, both using the same fieldtester
agent — the carrier picks the scope:

- **Per-cycle fieldtest** (the default this file otherwise
  describes): dispatched after a surface-touching cycle's audit,
  carrier scoped to that cycle (`cycle_id` / `cycle_scope`).
  Catches cycle-local friction early. Optional / orchestrator
  judgement, as below.
- **Milestone fieldtest**: the closing gate for a tracker
  milestone. Carrier scoped to the milestone's promise
  (`milestone_id` / `milestone_promise`); the fieldtester
  derives curated end-to-end scenarios top-down from that
  promise and proves the shipped implementation delivers it. Its
  green status roll-up is required before a surface-touching
  milestone may be closed.

Both carriers are defined authoritatively under **Carrier
contract** in `agents/fieldtester.md` (the milestone variant
under its **Milestone-scope variant** sub-heading). The gate the
milestone fieldtest feeds is defined once in
`../docs/pipeline.md` § Milestone-close gate — not restated
here. The milestone fieldtest is skippable on the same terms as
the per-cycle one, lifted to milestone level: a milestone whose
entire scope is internal (no user-visible surface) is exempt.

## Two tiers: probe and full

Orthogonal to scope, the **per-cycle** fieldtest runs at one of
two tiers. The orchestrator picks the tier at dispatch and
carries it in the carrier's `tier` field — the field, its
example bounds, and its report cap are defined authoritatively
under **Carrier contract** in `agents/fieldtester.md` and
deliberately not restated here:

- **Full** (the default; `tier` absent): one example per axis
  the cycle touched — the shape the rest of this file describes.
- **Probe**: for a cycle whose user-visible delta is a **single
  narrow axis** — one flag, one diagnostic, one configuration
  key. The carrier's `axis_hints` then names exactly that one
  axis. Field evidence (issue #35): a full fieldtest cost ~89k
  tokens on a one-flag cycle even at minimal example count, yet
  that same dispatch found a real self-description bug — the
  probe tier keeps that signal at a fraction of the cost.

**Probe is a tier, not a skip.** The skip rules below are
unchanged: a surface-touching cycle still runs its fieldtest;
probe merely right-sizes the dispatch when the surface delta is
one axis. A multi-axis cycle takes the full tier — when in
doubt, full.

**Both tiers run on the agent's frontmatter model.** A probe
dispatch changes scope, not model: its economy comes from the
one-axis cut and the capped report, while finding classification
stays on the opus judgement tier. (A `model: sonnet` probe
override was ratified and same-day retracted on review grounds —
field evidence is a judgement role per
`../docs/agent-template.md` § model rule 2, and the probe cut
lacks the deterministic gate the issue-#30 override rests on;
recorded on issue #35.) The **milestone fieldtest always runs
full tier** — its carrier takes no `tier` field.

## When to Use / Skipping

Triggers:

- Orchestrator-dispatched after audit closes cleanly, when
  the orchestrator believes the iteration is correct and
  wants a field test. The pre-condition is a clean (or
  ratified) audit; the trigger is the orchestrator's
  judgment-call that the iteration is complete.
- A shipped feature is suspected of being awkward in some
  way the earlier brainstorm could not foresee.
- A user-facing surface change has just landed.

Findings cluster around two shapes — simple bugs (route via
`debug` → `implement` mini) or catastrophic architecture
problems (route via next `brainstorm`). Friction and spec-gap
items are also possible; the routing table below applies in
all cases.

**Skipping is permitted only** for:

- Bug-fix iterations (use `debug`).
- Tidy iterations whose scope is purely internal cleanup with
  zero surface impact.
- Iterations whose entire scope is documentation.

**Skipping is not permitted** for:

- A cycle that introduced or changed surface syntax, schema,
  effects, API, configuration format, or any user-visible
  diagnostic.
- A cycle whose commit body or backlog issue claims "users
  can now do X". `fieldtest` is the gate that empirically
  substantiates such claims; an unverified claim is drift.

## The Iron Law

```
THE FIELDTESTER WORKS FROM THE PUBLIC INTERFACE ONLY — NOT FROM THE IMPLEMENTATION SOURCE.
EVERY EXAMPLE IS WRITTEN IN THE PROJECT'S CANONICAL AUTHORING / CONSUMER FORM.
EVERY FRICTION POINT AND BUG IS RECORDED. NONE IS WORKED AROUND.
```

The first clause is load-bearing: the whole point of the
field test is to simulate a downstream consumer who has only
the public interface. The agent file enforces this with a
hard path allowlist (computed from the project's public
interface, if it has one — its CLAUDE.md project facts); the
orchestrator must trust that contract
and not feed the agent implementation-internal hints in the
carrier.

## Dispatch

Dispatch `fieldtester` with the carrier from the Handoff
Contract below. The agent picks its examples per the dispatched
tier (bounds in the `tier` carrier row; on full, one per axis
the cycle touched — fewer loses the signal on variation, more
overflows one readable report), implements them as
downstream consumers, runs them, classifies findings, and
writes the spec. The two artefact kinds part ways at commit: the **fixtures are
committed as normal code** (they are consumer test assets — suggested
subject `fieldtest: <cycle> — <N> examples, <K> findings`), while the
**fieldtest spec is a git-ignored working file that is never committed**.

The fieldtest spec is written **after** cycle N's audit-close (fieldtest
runs only once audit is clean), so N's cycle-close sweep has already run
and cannot touch it — it survives naturally as an **input to the next
cycle's `planner`**. It is shell-`rm`'d at N+1's audit-close, whose sweep
removes every working-tree spec and plan (N+1's own, plus this spent
fieldtest spec). The `fieldtest-` prefix only marks it in the working
tree as the next cycle's input; it plays no part in the delete decision
(the sweep removes everything present).

## Handoff Contract

`fieldtest` consumes (from orchestrator at cycle close) the carrier
fields `cycle_id`, `cycle_scope`, `axis_hints`, `commit_range`, and
`tier`, defined authoritatively under **Carrier contract** in
`agents/fieldtester.md` (which also specifies the empty-`axis_hints`
fallback and the absent-`tier` default).

`fieldtest` produces, for the orchestrator, the fields `spec_path`,
`examples_added`, and `findings`, defined authoritatively under
**Output format** in `agents/fieldtester.md` — single-sourced in
the agent file, deliberately not restated here so the two files
cannot drift.

It additionally reports one skill-level `status` roll-up — one of
`clean` / `friction_found` / `bugs_found` / `infra_blocked`. This
field is owned here (it is not part of the agent's per-run status
protocol), so it is defined in this file only.

The orchestrator drives downstream:

- `bug` → `debug` (RED-first; GREEN via `implement` mini-mode)
- `friction` → next `brainstorm` or a tidy iteration via
  `planner`
- `spec_gap` → ratify by updating the design ledger (and
  naming the gap in the closing commit body), or tighten the
  design ledger
- `working` → carry-on (worth recording, no follow-up)

`fieldtest` does NOT self-resolve.

**Tracker filing — bundle by default.** A fieldtest typically
yields more findings than a cycle closes issues (3-5 vs 1-2 in
the field evidence on issue #36), so filing each finding as its
own issue grows the tracker structurally with every fieldtested
cycle. When findings are filed onto the tracker rather than
routed inline:

- Consolidate before filing: before creating **any** new issue,
  check whether an open issue on the same line of work can
  carry the scope — absorb via a comment there instead.
- Related `friction` / `spec_gap` findings of one fieldtest go
  into **one collective issue**, not one issue per finding.
- A real `bug` keeps its own issue — it is a forward-queue work
  item. A low-severity bug may wait in the collective issue
  instead.
- The fieldtester's report stays per-finding — classification
  is the agent's contract and does not change. Bundling is this
  orchestrator-side filing rule only. The writes themselves
  follow `../issue/SKILL.md`, as every tracker write does.

When settled single-issue items accumulate anyway, the
orchestrator drains them as a **harvest sweep** — the batch
shape defined in `../docs/pipeline.md` § Harvest sweep.

## Cross-references

- **Agent dispatched:** `agents/fieldtester.md` — carries the
  five-phase process, the Iron Law in operational form, the
  spec template, the per-finding classification rules, the
  Common Rationalisations table, and the Red Flags list.
- **Upstream gate:** `../audit/SKILL.md` runs first;
  fieldtest comes after a clean (or ratified) audit.
- **Closing gate it feeds:** `../docs/pipeline.md`
  § Milestone-close gate — the milestone fieldtest's green
  roll-up is the functional leg of that gate.
- **Batch drain it feeds:** `../docs/pipeline.md`
  § Harvest sweep — the batch shape that drains accumulated
  settled single-issue items (bundled findings included).
- **Cadence ordering:** fieldtest runs *before*
  `../docwriter/SKILL.md`; docwriter happens at a later,
  longer stability window.
- **Downstream targets:**
  - `../debug/SKILL.md` — for each `bug` finding
  - `../brainstorm/SKILL.md` or `../planner/SKILL.md` — for
    `friction` and `spec_gap` findings worth a follow-up
    iteration